fredag 1. november 2013

Henny Baareim


Assignment #3: Birth rate and Ideology


6 Nations with Roman Catholic Ideology

Italy
Roman Catholic: 80%
Birth rate: 8.94 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 3.33 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 81.95 years
Average Income: $30,600
Average Education Level: 16 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 62.7%

Brazil
Roman Catholic: 73,6%
Birth Rate: 14.97 births /1000
Infant Mortality: 19.83 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 73.02 years
Average Income: $12,100
Average Education Level: 14 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 80.3%
Spain
Roman Catholic: 94%
Birth Rate: 10.14 births/1000
Infant Mortality 3.35 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 81.37 years
Average Income: $31,100
Average Education Level: 17 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 65.7%

Ecuador
Roman Catholic: 95%
Birth Rate: 19.23 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 5.03 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 76.15
Average Income: $10,200
Average Education Level: 14 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 72.7%
Mexico
Roman Catholic: 82,7%
Birth rate: 18.61 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 16.26 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 76.86 years
Average Income: $15,600
Average Education level: 14 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 70.9%

Luxembourg
Roman Catholic: 87%
Birth Rate: 11.72 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 4.33 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 79.88 years
Average Income: $81,100
Average Education Level: 14 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: Unknown





























3 Nations not opposed to birth control


Norway
Roman Catholic: 1%
Birth Rate: 10.8 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 3.47 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 80.44 years
Average Income: $55,900
Average Education Level: 18 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 88.4%

Estonia
Roman Catholic: 1,4%
Birth Rate: 10.38 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 6.82 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 73.82 years
Average Income: $22,100
Average Education Level: 16 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 63.4%
Malawi
Roman Catholic: 0%
Birth Rate: 39.98 births/1000
Infant Mortality: 76.98 deaths/1000
Average Lifespan: 52.78 years
Average Income: $900
Average Education Level: 11 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 46.1%




Conclusion

In my study on the countries with high percentage of Roman Catholic ideology I included birth rate, infant mortality, average lifespan, income and education level. Also I included the rate of contraceptive prevalence. I chose Italy, Brazil, Spain, Ecuador, Mexico and Luxembourg, all with catholic percent over 70%. With these numbers one can see, despite high percentage of Roman Catholics, there is also a moderate high contraceptive prevalence. The lowest rate, when it comes to usage of contraceptive is 62.7%, which proves that there are no correlation between the technological conservative prohibition against birth control and the practicing of Roman Catholic ideology in these countries. Mexico and Ecuador is the only two countries that correlate with high catholic practicing and high birth rate. However, at the same time they both have a high rate of using birth control.


Further I added three more countries which do not practice an ideology which oppose birth control; Norway, Estonia and Malawi. All in all there are four countries with significant higher birth rate than the others; Brazil, Ecuador, Mexico and Malawi. Three of these countries are practicing catholic ideology and are, surprisingly, among the highest birth control rates. This shows that the practice of Roman Catholic Ideology does not affect the contraceptive prevalence, thus not birth rate either.

There seems to be a correlation between the countries with high birth rate, and a low income. All the four countries have a low income, if we define low income everything under $25,000, which is reasonable when we compare them to the other countries. Along with this, the education level is at its lowest here. Also typical when high birth rate is the high infant mortality. This goes especially for Brazil, Mexico and Malawi, which also have the lowest average lifespan, when we include Ecuador.

An exception from all of this, we have Estonia. They are not Catholic, have a low birth rate and low infant mortality, along with low average lifespan. In addition, they have, after defining above, a low income. This country is an example of how one would think it works, low income – low birth rate, when it is actually opposite looking at the statistics. They are also among those with the lowest usage of birth control.


When we look at the numbers all together, we can view similarities among the countries with low poverty level. They produce many children, and have a high infant mortality. In theory this is called r-selection. Also they have low income, which provides an unstable environment for the children. In addition they have low average lifespan. The opposite of this is the k-selection, which have high income, low birth rate, low infant mortality and high average lifespan, as well as higher education level. This proves that the more unstable environment, the more children will be produced.


Helene Instanes




Though there is a technologically conservative prohibition against birth control among Catholic populations, does this prohibition really exist in behavior?

According to the countries that I have chosen, it seems like the prohibition of birth control does not affect the population. Malta, one of the countries I have chosen consists of 98 % Catholics, however the contraceptive prevalence rate is the highest among my 9 countries. When looking at the Catholic countries and the percentage of the population, which is using contraceptive, the number, are higher in the Catholic countries compared to the non-Catholic countries. Malta, Argentina and Colombia are basically the countries with the highest percentage of Catholics, and also have the highest percentage of birth control use. This indicates that the technologically conservative prohibition against birth control among the Catholic population is proves wrong and is not consistent when it comes to the Catholic Ideology.

Does Catholic prohibition really have an influence on birth control use (reflected in a high birth rate) or do other factors appear to play a greater role in birth rate (poverty, education, infant mortality rate, short average lifespan, etc.)?


When looking at the countries with some of the highest birth rates, Philippines, Somalia and Indonesia, we can see that they have some things in common, but only Philippines is Catholic. All of them have an average income below $14,000, they have the lowest average lifespan, the lowest percentage of birth control use, and also have the lowest educational level among the selected countries. These are all different factors that can contribute to a high birth rate. Low income can indicate that they do not have money to spend on birth control. Which can be strengthening by looking at the percentage of birth control use in these countries. However these countries also have some of the lowest educational levels among the countries, which can indicate that they have not learned about birth control.

However two of the Catholic countries with the highest percentage of Catholics, Malta and Monaco, have the lowest percentage of birth rate. They also have the highest average income and lowest percentage of infant mortality. Compared to the other Catholic countries, Philippines, with high birth rate, we find that the differences is that high income equals less children, and low income equals many children. Also the average lifespan is higher in Malta and Monaco, which shows that life quality is higher in these countries.

Among my countries, the country with the lowest percentage of birth control use is Somalia. Where the birth rate also is the highest with 41,45 births per 1000. In addition, Somalia is the poorest country and also has the lowest education and average lifespan.

Conclusion
The Catholic prohibition does not seem to have a great influence on birth control use in the countries that I have chosen. By looking at these statistics from these countries we can conclude that the r/K theory is consistent. K-selection countries have a greater average income like Monaco, Malta and Iceland and also tend to have a lower birthrate and infant mortality rate. This can also indicate that they have a stabile environment. However, r- selection countries show to have a low average income and also have a high birth rate and also an infant mortality rate. These countries tend also to be the one who uses less birth control, and have a lower average lifespan, which might mean that they have an unstable environment and might produce a lot of kids so that they are sure some of them will actually grow up. Examples can be Somalia, Philippines and Indonesia.


Maria Tomren


Birth Rate and Ideology
The purpose of this assignment is to investigate the impact of catholic ideology on a country's birth rates. The countries chosen for this comparison are Italy, Spain, Belgium, Mexico, Argentina and the Philippines which have a catholic population of at least 75 %, and the countries Greece, Indonesia and Sweden with catholic populations of 3 percent or less. In addition to percentage of catholic population, the variables infant mortality rate, life expectancy at birth, school life expectancy, maternal mortality rate and GDP per capita is used as independent variables to describe variations in birth rate.


Italy
Spain
Belgium
Mexico
Argentina
Philippines
Greece
Indonesia
Sweden
Catholic population
80 %
94 %
75 %
82.7 %
92 %
82.9 %
> 0.7 %
3 %
> 3 %
Birth rate per 1,000
8.94
10.14
10
18.61
17.12
24.62
8.94
17.38
10.2
Infant mortality rate per 1,000
3.33
3.35
4.23
16.26
10.24
18.19
4.85
26.06
4.14
Life expectancy at birth
81.95
81.37
79.78
76.86
77.32
72.21
80.18
71.9
78.94
School life expectancy
16
17
16
14
16
11
16
13
17
Maternal mortality rate per 100,000
4
6
8
50
77
99
3
220
12
GDP per capita
$30,600
$31,100
$38,500
$15,600
$18,400
$4,500
$24,900
$5,100
$38,300

From studying the statistics, we can observe that similar countries, such as the European countries Italy, Spain, Belgium, Greece and Sweden have similar birth rates that are apperantly independent of the percentage of catholic populations. The non-European countries Mexico, Argentina, Philippines and Indonesia have substantially higher birth rates than the European countries, but the difference appears to be more related to lower health standards (higher infant mortality rate, and maternal mortality rate), economic factors (lower GDP per capita) and lower education (shorter school life expectancy) than with the catholic percentage of the population.

Using ordinary least squares to evaluate the independent variable's effect on birth rate, two variables are statistically significant with a p-value of less than 5 percent. These two variables are catholic population and life expectancy. If the test is run again with just these variables, their coefficients are 0.0557 and -1.44 respectively. These two factors explain 93 percent of the variation in birth rates.

This shows that a higher percentage of catholics in a country is indeed positively related with the birth rate, implying that the prohibition against birth contraceptives is indeed a cultural factor that increases birth rates. However the impact of ideology is small compared to the impact of life expectancy which is negatively correlated with birth rates. A high life expectancy implies good overall good health in the population and a more stable environment, so it is expected that high life expectancy is negatively correlated with birth rates. High life expectancy is probably dependent on the other independent variables, so this is could explain why these are not statistically significant in this analysis, even though they probably do affect birth rate in reality.

So even though religious ideology has some impact on the birth rate in a country, other factors such as health which life expectancy has much higher importance in explaining differences in birth rates.